Read Later: Download this Post as PDF >> CLICK HERE

Addressing Neurogenic Thoracic Outlet Syndrome

Image 1: Double Crush Syndrome

The term double crush syndrome (DCS) was coined by Harvard University plastic surgeons Albert Upton and Alan McComas, who wrote, “Neural function is impaired when compressed axons at one site cause the nerve to become especially susceptible to damage at another site” (Image 1). Their double crush research began after observing that many carpal, cubital, and radial tunnel patients also complained of unilateral shoulder, chest, and upper back pain.1 While the DCS mechanism is not completely understood, it likely involves nerve sensitization and neuroplastic changes in the pain-modulating systems of the brain and spinal cord.
Neural compression of the brachial plexus is suitably called neurogenic thoracic outlet syndrome (NTOS). These clients present with a variety of symptoms, including painless atrophy of intrinsic hand muscles and nighttime paresthesia. Athletes may have difficulty grasping a racquet or ball, and some report pain. However, I’ve found that rather than being a main pain event, NTOS is more of an enhancer of symptoms at a distal site, such as the carpal tunnel. Put simply, the brain pays more attention to double crush nerve insults and is more likely to respond with pain or spasm.

Although most clinicians feel that NTOS is an underestimated cause of DCS, assessment is often difficult due to vague, fluctuating symptoms. Instead of chasing the pain, I’ve achieved superior outcomes by palpating and releasing all fibrous connective tissue sites that may be kinking, stretching, or inflaming the brachial plexus. In the January/February 2016 (“An Alternate Approach to Tennis Elbow,” page 102) and May/June 2016 (“Carpal Tunnel Syndrome Revisited,” page 102) issues of Massage & Bodywork, I addressed carpal and radial tunnel compression sites. Now, we’ll palpate and release NTOS contractures at the interscalene triangle, costoclavicular canal, and retropectoralis minor spaces (Image 2).

Image 2: Interscalene costoclavicular, & retropectoralis compression sites

INTERSCALENE IMPINGEMENT

Nerve fibers originating at the spinal cord travel from the neck, through the thoracic outlet, and into the hand, providing sensation and movement during daily tasks. Certain postures or sleeping positions may increase tension and pressure on entrapped nerves.

Further complicating the nerve’s journey through the thoracic outlet, researcher David B. Roos, MD, FACS, discovered irregular fibrous bands that increased brachial plexus stiffness and decreased movement.2 Roos classified 10 types of contractures that can stiffen the already unforgiving boundaries of the thoracic outlet container. Despite all the neural roadblocks, it has been my experience that many DCS clients respond well to massage, movement, and any type of cognitive training that lowers the brain’s threat level during movement. In Image 3, I demonstrate my favorite anterior and middle scalene stretch to create space at the interscalene triangle.

Image 3: Interscalene triangle: (A) With the client’s head left rotated, my soft-cupped fingers wade behind the sternocleidomastoid and onto the scale attachments at the transverse processes. (B) By left-rotating and slowly extending the client’s neck, I palpate for scalene adhesions and pin stretch to release.

SUBCLAVIUS AND THE COSTOCLAVICULAR CANAL

In clients with a drooping clavicle, the underlying subclavius muscle can reduce the costoclavicular canal size and compress the brachial plexus against the first rib. Upper chest breathing can exacerbate the problem, as the first rib elevates during inhalation and can get stuck there. A 2015 study published in BMC Research Notes also noted brachial compression from the subclavius posticus muscle, which ties the first rib to the superior border of the scapula.3 Rather than dig in to the sensitive tissues under the clavicle, I always begin with the subclavius stretch demonstrated in Image 4. This slow, gentle, graded exposure stretch is designed to reassure the brain that it’s now safe to move in previously painful positions.

Image 4: Subclavius stretch: The client’s arm rest on my shoulder, and my right hand’s curled fingers snake behind the clavicle and brace while my left fingers wade in front of the upper trapezius and contact the scalenes where they attach to the first rib. To create space and stretch the subclavius, I simply extend my knees and abduct her arm, allowing my fingers to spread open the thoracic outlet.

RETROPECTORALIS MUSCLE IMPINGEMENT

Repetitive movements of the arms above the head, common among tennis enthusiasts, may cause friction and overstretch the nerve plexus under the pectoralis minor at the coracoid. The least irritating way I’ve found to create space here is by stretching the distal fibers that attach to ribs 3, 4, and 5. Notice in Image 5 that the stretch is directed at a 135-degree angle, which is the approximate pectoralis muscle fiber angle from coracoid to the rib insertions.

Image 5: Pectoralis minor: With the client’s hand resting on her neck, my left hand grasps her arm, and my right palm braces her scapula. As she inhales and gently pulls her elbow toward the therapy table, I resist to a count of five. Upon exhalation, a counterforce is created as I pull with my left hand and brace with my right hand, feeling for a stretch in the pectoralis minor fibers at ribs 3, 4, and 5

Many NTOS studies recommend postural correction, including muscle strengthening and lengthening for double crush complaints. However, there is no consensus in the literature as to exactly which muscles should be targeted. Posture is dynamic and the best results are gained through whole-body strengthening and balancing programs such as swimming, yoga, and martial arts. The bodywork goal is to bring mental awareness to areas of restriction and to teach the client it is safe to move through those previously painful barriers.

Erik Dalton is the executive director of the Freedom from Pain Institute. Educated in massage, osteopathy, and Rolfing, Dalton has maintained a practice in Oklahoma City, Oklahoma, for more than three decades. 

Notes

1. A. R. Upton and A. J. McComas, “The Double Crush in Nerve Entrapment Syndromes,” Lancet 2, no. 7825 (August 1973): 359–62.

2. D. B. Roos, “The Thoracic Outlet Syndrome is Underrated,” Archives of Neurology 47, no. 3 (1990): 327–28.

3. J. Muellner et al., “Neurogenic Thoracic Outlet Syndrome Due to Subclavius Posticus Muscle with Dynamic Brachial Plexus Compression: A Case Report,” BMC Research Notes 8, no. 351 (August 2015). doi:10.1186/s13104-015-1317-3.

Techniques & more demonstrated in the
Treating Trapped Nerves Home-Study

16 CE Hours Included in this course

Treating Trapped Nerves MAT Home Study Course
with Online Test and Printed Test.

Take the test from your computer whenever you want,
or fill the test out when you’re ready, and send it to our office for review.