Addressing Postural Plasticity
by Erik Dalton
In the early 1990s, I had the opportunity to study with legendary neurologist and physiotherapist Vladimir Janda, M.D. He and his research team at Charles University in Prague, Czechoslovakia, were among the first to perform EMG studies showing that some muscles weaken and others tighten when exposed to prolonged stress.1 In the course of their research, one unexpected length-strength muscle imbalance pattern appeared in people with forward head carriage (Figure 1).
In the illustration, notice how the tight and weak muscles form a crossing pattern, which Janda and his team called Upper Cross Syndrome (UCS). In an effort to expound on Janda’s findings, my graphic designer and I created an image called “The 42 Pound Head” (Figure 2). This shows how the feeling of head weight increases by 10 pounds for every inch the head moves forward of the shoulders.
Janda’s UCS muscle imbalance theory has become widely popularized as an easy-to-visualize assessment tool. However, it has met with harsh criticism from researchers who did not find the pattern to be a reliable marker of pain. In an attempt to upgrade Janda’s research using current brain-based understandings, I’ll review the evolution of upright head posture and discuss the neurologic role of muscular imbalance. I’ll also demonstrate myoskeletal graded exposure techniques I’ve found helpful in relieving postural stress, improving cognition and increasing body awareness.
A wider horizon
One of the evolutionary advantages of erect head-on-neck posture is that it establishes ease of head rotation around a vertical axis, which serves to widen our horizon. In early man, the need to stabilize this sensory platform to track prey was essential for survival. Famed research anthropologist José Luis Alatorre Warren at the University of Zurich found evolutionary changes in the size and positioning of the cranium largely resulted from adaptations necessary for bipedal upright walking.2 To ensure optimal head-on-neck balance, the opening at the occiput for the spinal cord (foramen magnum) was forced to migrate forward during human evolution. There are many possible explanations why Mother Nature considers a balanced head so desirable for upright humans, but the most obvious one is improved visual tracking.
Head orientation and cranial teleceptors
The human head houses sensory organs called cranial teleceptors that connect us to the outside world. When floating comfortably atop the spine, these intricate receptors reflexively orient head placement using light, sound and gravitational sensory information. In fact, our eyes must constantly move, via saccades, to allow light to traverse across the retina. This allows the central nervous system to construct visual images by comparing adjoining structures in our environment. Therefore, our brains are often unable to make sense of visual input without proper head-on-neck movement.
Unfortunately, teleceptor function is often compromised due to postural ergonomic stress, micro- and macro-traumatic events, and accompanying inflammation. In time, failure of the smooth self-regulating function of these receptors results in a catch-22 cycle, as faulty alignment initiates head-righting reflexes that trigger muscle spasm and mechanically alter spinal joint motion (Figure 3).
As hyperexcited joint and ligament mechanoreceptors initiate protective splinting, some muscles overwork and others become neurologically inhibited, as seen in Janda’s UCS. This results in reduced mobility, excessive energy consumption, exhaustion and, if the brain perceives threat, pain. However, such cranial teleceptor malfunction and head-righting reflexes may not be the only neurological explanation for the commonly seen muscular imbalance pattern Janda encountered in his UCS research.
The SAID Principle
The SAID principle—an acronym for Specific Adaptation to Imposed Demands—is a classic sports medicine term describing how physical adaptations develop when the body is placed under stress, thereby allowing us to better handle future stressors. Simply put, the body gets better at doing whatever it does regularly.
If that means sitting for hours in a desk-occupied posture or performing exercises using poor form, the brain will accommodate by adopting poor form and less than perfect posture (Figure 4). I call this brain-body adaptation process “postural plasticity” and believe it to be a valuable assessment tool for identifying possible roots of suboptimal posture and inefficient movement.
Weak postural patterns such as Janda’s UCS may begin as “tissue issues” due to tension, trauma or overuse injuries, but eventually they manifest as signs of functional weakness in the brain’s hardware.
Pontomedullary Reticular Formation (PMRF)
The PMRF is a dynamic sorting and switching station located in the brainstem at the pontomedullary junction, where pons meets the medulla (Figure 5). Considered the epicenter for postural control, the PMRF houses eight cranial nerves that perform vital sensory and motor functions, including vestibulo-ocular (eye and ear) coordination. The PMRF is assigned the tasks of regulating head-righting reflexes, maintaining balanced gait and, when functioning optimally, inhibiting cervicothoracic flexion and resisting gravitationally induced slumping.
Clients with bilateral PMRF disorders commonly present with UCS postural symptoms, such as forward jutted chins, internally rotated arms, protracted shoulders and thoracic spine hyperkyphosis. In this population, the PMRF is unable to neurologically resist slumping, which leads to connective tissue and joint adaptations as seen in Janda’s UCS model.
Assessment and correction
It’s best to assess for PMRF weakness with the client unaware they’re being examined. I begin by observing my client’s posture and gait as they enter the office, looking for front-to-back and side-to-side rotational strain patterns that may indicate PMRF weakness. During the intake evaluation, I’m watching for things such as motor dominance patterns, eye unleveling and cross-lateral gait disturbances, which may offer clues to unilateral or bilateral PMRF weakness. I find weeding out these common compensatory patterns early on in therapy provides a good starting point for more specific assessment and treatment interventions to follow.
In Figure 6, I assess for unilateral PMRF weakness using a modified wall angel. The client is asked to sidebend around my finger fulcrum placed on his sternum while keeping his chin tucked and thorax and hands in contact with the wall. Notice that as he left sidebends, his shoulder and hand leave the wall and his chin juts forward. To help stimulates his postural reflexes and improve his unilateral PMRF weakness, I perform a graded exposure myoskeletal technique.
I begin by left rotating and extending his head, abducting his arm, and placing a soft palm on his chest wall. He is asked to slowly begin externally and internally rotating his arm while I apply hand pressure to various spots on his anterior shoulder and chest to bring awareness to areas of restriction (Figure 7). Then, I retest for improved quality of motion. If the client had presented with bilateral PMRF weakness, I could have performed a cross-armed shoulder depression technique by asking him to inhale, protract his shoulders against my resistance to a count of five, exhale and relax (Figure 8).
- Janda, V. (1972). What is the typical upright posture in man? Journal of Czech Physicians, 111(32), 748-750.
- Alatorre Warren, J.L., Ponce de León, M.S., Hopkins, W.D., & Zollikofer, C.P.E. (2019). Evidence for independent brain and neurocranial reorganization during hominin evolution. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 116(44), 22,115-22,121.
On sale this week only!
Save 25% off the Upper Body Course!
Learn unique approaches for working with the shoulder girdle, arms, neck and torso. This course provides you with the skills you need to confidently relieve pain issues in the upper body. (22CE)
Save 25% off the Upper Body Course this week only. Offer expires June 27th. Click the button below for more information and to purchase the course for CE hours and a certificate of completion to display in your office. Bonus: When you order the Home Study version, get the eLearning course for free!