Bodywork is like chewing on a stick
Nearly a century ago, Hans Selye began his pioneering research into the human stress response by providing convincing evidence that stress impacted health.1 While many scientists took Selye’s experiments and interpretations at face value, not all agreed with his strict physiological view of the body as a tightly controlled input-output machine where the degree of stress always resulted in a predictable hormonal response.
One of those critics was Rockefeller researcher Jay Weiss who in a series of laboratory experiments delivered mild electric shocks, equivalent to static electricity, to a rat over a period of time causing it to develop a prolonged stress response including elevated heart rate, increased cortisol secretion, and eventually an ulcer.2
Meantime, in the next room, a different rat was receiving an identical series of shocks at exactly the same time using the same intensity. But in the case of rat number two, after receiving the shock, he was allowed to run over to a stick of wood in the corner of the cage and gnaw on it (Image 1). In an instant, Han Selye’s tightly regulated biological stress model completely collapsed as Wise and his team retested rat #2 and found that blood pressure and resting cortisol levels had suddenly dropped simply by offering a stick of wood to act as a psychological outlet for the rat’s frustration. Good hands-on bodywork is in many ways like the “chewing on a stick” experiment.
As we will see in this column, touch therapy has proven to be an effective outlet for relieving frustration, aggression and anxiety in this stressed out country we call home.
Touch as a compassion outlet
We are better at dealing with both acute and chronic stressors when we have outlets for our frustration like punching a wall (not recommended), taking a run or getting a massage. Touch is powerful and our need for it is primordial. Where most species evolved to survive in specific ecological environments, humans adapted to survive in groups. This discrepancy goes a long way toward explaining why touch therapy is so important in warding off our client’s tendency toward loneliness, anxiety and depression.
In order to relax, the brain needs to know it has backup—someone it trusts to offer help should the need arise—and physical contact through touch therapy is the simplest, most powerful way of communicating those feelings of support. Nothing is more psychologically concrete than human touch and our hands are the perfect, unambiguous tool for expressing emotional reassurance. Because the human hand is densely embedded with refined sensory receptors that receive and process proprioceptive information about the things we touch, they are our body’s way of exploring and manipulating the world, and also our primary language of expression and compassion.
One recent study published in Scientific Reports suggest that slow, affective touch may help modulate the perception of physical pain thus strengthening social bonding while reducing the stress response.3
So, the burning questions for manual therapists is how do we identify those chronically stressed clients entering our offices—how do we converse with them to make them feel safe—and what types of hands on techniques might prove helpful in reducing their allostatic load and calming their hijacked nervous systems?
Observation, Listening and Compassionate Touch
Here are some physical stress response signs I typically observe for when a client enters my workplace:
- Bug-eyed and disoriented
- Clenched jaw
- Shallow breathing
- Rigid or slumped body postures
When dealing with a client exhibiting any of the above symptoms, I make sure they know they have my full-undivided attention. I always listen calmly and empathetically before proceeding with the hands-on work. However, if they appear too disoriented or distracted, I typically try and get them on the therapy table as quickly as possible and in some cases, cover them with a lightweight blanket gently tucked to the sides of their body. Once they’re comfortably situated, I begin applying slow graded exposure suboccipital and upper cervical myoskeletal techniques such as those shown in Images 2, 3 and 4.
Because the suboccipitals and other upper cervical muscles are innervated with both skeletal and cranial nerves, this is the epicenter for establishing serene body-brain communication. To help down-regulate the client’s hyperexcited fear center (amygdala) and stimulate parasympathetic tone via the vagus nerve, I perform a variety of oscillating and slow affective touch techniques while observing for any positive physical and/or emotional changes. As the client’s tissues soften and the protective guarding diminishes,
the client will often begin making intermittent eye contact. At this point I begin verbally engaging their prefrontal cortex with suggestions that they have come to the right place and by working as a team, we will help them recover their feelings of strength, safety and confidence.
Even in a optimally functioning body, maintaining allostatic balance is a challenge given the multitude of factors constantly taxing our bodies creating physical, chemical and emotional stress. In most settings, stress is vital for our protection and performance by helping keep us safe and ready to succeed. It would seem stress is only bad when it becomes “distress” at elevated levels for prolonged periods of time.
Han Selye’s research has taught us that stress is a normal bodily function in most animals and hardwired into our biological operating system to help us cope and meet challenges. Yet, we must remember that good bodywork is like chewing on a stick when it comes to relieving the frustration, aggression and anxiety associated with the psychological symptoms of stress.
1. Siang Yong Tan, Yip A, Hans Seyle: Founder of the stress theory, Singapore Med J. 2018
2. Weiss, J. M. Effects of coping responses on stress. Journal of Comparative and Physiological Psychology, 1968, 65, 251-260
3. Mohr M, Kirsh P, Fotoulou A, The soothing function of touch: affective touch reduces feelings of social exclusion, Scientific Reports, 2017
On sale this week only!
Save 25% off the Technique Tour course!
Discover deep tissue, pin and stretch, nerve mobilization, and graded exposure stretches in this comprehensive “technique only” program. Save 25% this week only. Offer expires September 28th. Click the button below for more information and to purchase the course for CE hours and a certificate of completion to display in your office.
BONUS: Order the home study version and get access to the eCourse for free!